Drain Tile Dilemma

Drain tile, something I know all too well, growing up in eastern North Dakota, where a good share of all farmland is drain-tiled. Let me preface by saying that I'm a firm believer in landowner rights. My in-laws farmed, and I have many friends and family who are farmers and ranchers. You absolutely have the right to run your operation how you see fit. We all know how difficult it is for our farmers and ranchers to make it these days, with rising costs on just about everything, including fuel.

What is Drain Tile

Simply stated, drain tile is a system of perforated pipes buried underground around a home's foundation or beneath an agricultural field to collect excess groundwater and channel it away. In an agricultural field, drain tile eliminates standing water and sends it into a nearby ditch, where gravity eventually carries it into a river or lake.

Agricultural tile is buried 3 to 4 feet deep in farm fields to lower the water table and prevent the soil from staying waterlogged. If you own prime farmland, drain tile is an attractive option to make sure you can get into your fields early, and increased crop yields would be the two biggest benefits for landowners.

The Downfalls of Drain Tile

Take a look at this map showing drain tile permits in North Dakota. The majority are in the Red River Valley, the Devils Lake Region, and southeast North Dakota. It's no coincidence; these are the areas of the state that flood the most. That water has to run off somewhere, and that's why the Red River chronically floods, and drain tile has been a big contributor to Devils Lake swallowing up, ironically, mass amounts of farmland.

But wait, there's more. Drain tile hurts other areas of the environment. According to this post on Facebook, 60% of the wetlands in North Dakota have already been lost. Duck populations are suffering, along with other wildlife such as upland game birds, and even deer and other big game. Wetlands also naturally improve our water quality and filtration, provide storm control, and store fresh water. This is all lost when you drain tile.

Drain Tile Moving West

I was literally shocked recently when I was driving by a piece of land north of Sterling, North Dakota, where I have been hunting ducks, geese, and pheasants for years, and it was being drain-tiled. This quarter section of land had only a handful of sloughs on it; the majority of the time they were dry, but they always held pheasants. The field also traditionally held thousands of migrating ducks and geese feeding on waste grain. Not anymore. I drove by it yesterday, and every inch of that land has been plowed and is now void of any wildlife whatsoever.

In a span of about a month, this land has been changed forever. What is a head-scratcher to me is that this land didn't have very many sloughs to begin with. Drain tile can be expensive, and I can't imagine it is cost-effective on this piece of land. The cost of drain-tiling a quarter section of land can be up to $320,000.

Like one of my landowner friends told me before. If you drain-tile your land, you are sending your problems down the line to someone else. It can be an ethical dilemma.

What's an Alternative to Drain Tile

That would be the million-dollar question. Many farmers and ranchers these days are barely hanging on. Many are looking for any advantages they can get just to make a living and keep their operations afloat. You can't fault that.

One thing that could help would be if the federal government stepped in with better CRP prices. Marginal farmland could be enrolled in CRP, and wetlands could be saved. People and wildlife all benefit. Most of the farmers I talk to say that CRP prices just aren't competitive enough in this difficult time for farmers. This might be the best alternative to drain tile. Time for the government to step up.

 

 

 

 

 

The 14 Most Polluted Lakes In North Dakota

The 8 Most Snake Infested Waters In North Dakota